We are often asked what are the best places to eat on St. John.  Here is a list of our personal favorites…. in no particular order. 

Casual Dining

Cruz Bay Landing (Breakfast, Lunch and Dinner) 

Longboard (happy hour and dinner) 

Lime Inn (lunch and dinner)

Morgan’s Mango (dinner – make reservations)

Cafe Roma (pizza- dinner)

Greengo’s (Mexican- lunch and dinner)

Banana Deck (lunch and dinner)

de Coal Pot (local food)

Gecko Gazebo/Sun Dog Café (brunch, lunch and dinner)

Hercules (local food)

Margarita Phil’s (Mexican)

Ronnie’s Pizza (pizza)

Tap and Still (burgers)

Uncle Joe’s (BBQ)

Bar Dining

Tap Room (lunch and dinner- at Mongoose Junction. Great local beer) 

Woody’s (dive bar)

420 to Center (sports bar)

Cap’s Place (local food)

Dog House Pub (sports bar)

Hillside Terrace (local food)

Nella’s Lounge (local food)

Quiet Mon (Irish)

Fine Dining 

Ocean 362 (dinner, located at Gallows, sit at the bar and watch the sunset- make reservations and request the upstairs bar) 

The Terrace (make reservations)

Extra Virgin (make reservations)

La Tapa (menu changes daily – make reservations)

1864 Restaurant  Lunch and Dinner) 

 Beach Dining 

Drink (just a bar but it is awesome)

High Tide (on the beach, breakfast, lunch, dinner)

Bikinis on the Beach (at Honeymoon Beach)

Deli Style – To Go

Sam and Jacks (lunch- deli- also provisioning)

North Shore Deli (breakfast and lunch)

Little Olive (food truck, open W-F lunch/dinner pick up) 

Shaibu’s Gourmet Grab and Go (2nd floor marketplace)

Food “Shops”

Island Cork (wine and provisioning)

St. John Provisions (coffee shop)

Papaya Café (coffee and book shop)

Bajo el Sol Art Bar

Dessert

St. John Scoops (super yummy ice cream and more)

Columbo’s Smoothie Stand (on Centerline Road)

Cool Desires Ice Cream (home of the 16oz drink)

Irie Pops (RJ’s favorite)

Our Market Smoothies

On the other side, Coral Bay. 

Aqua Bistro (lunch and dinner) 

Skinny Legs (lunch and dinner) 

Miss Lucy’s (lunch and dinner)

Coral Bay Caribbean Oasis (dinner)

Rhumb Lines/Indigo Grill (dinner)

Lime Out (floating taco bar)

Pickles in Paradise (deli style)

Pizza Bar In Paradise (pizza)

TBD Restaurant (Isola Shopping Center)